Review of The Wayfinder by Adam Johnson
When I first picked up The Wayfinder, it was with a sense of excitement mixed with trepidation. Adam Johnson, the Pulitzer Prize-winning author of The Orphan Master’s Son, is known for his ability to weave intricate narratives filled with emotion and depth. As someone who has a profound appreciation for the rich tapestry of Polynesian culture and history, I was eager to see how Johnson would interpret these elements within the expansive scope of this epic tale. And while The Wayfinder certainly delivers a grand journey filled with action and drama, I found myself grappling with some familiar narratives in a beautifully constructed world.
The story revolves around Kōrero, a girl marked for destiny on her beleaguered Polynesian isle, preparing to confront the challenges of survival and power. Right off the bat, I felt an echo of Moana—yet as I delved deeper, I realized Johnson’s narrative is layered with complexity, diving into the intricacies of war, family, and cultural heritage. The novel alternates between two timelines—Kōrero’s adventure, expressed in a vivid first-person voice, and the political turmoil of Tonga, presented through an array of characters in the third person. Johnson’s ability to navigate these timelines is commendable, creating a rhythm that feels both natural and compelling. Some of the scenes struck deep emotional chords within me, especially a particularly heart-wrenching moment that had me in tears as the stakes rose to their peak.
Character-wise, it’s a veritable feast. We meet a plethora of perspectives—from the ailing king Tui to his ambitious sons, and even a talking parrot—creating a delightful yet occasionally dizzying family tree. I found myself hastily scribbling relationships and motivations (thank goodness for my trusty notebook!), a testament to the novel’s immersive realm, although I wish the promised map had been included to guide me through these waters.
However, despite its vibrancy, the narrative style felt a touch restrained. Johnson is undeniably skilled, but there were moments where I longed for a little more flair in his prose. The dual narratives often blended together in a way that dulled the sharp edges of the characters’ distinct voices. While the emphasis on economy in writing kept the pacing brisk, at times, it left the world feeling almost underseasoned, lacking in the lush descriptiveness I had anticipated.
Themes of story, words, and heritage echo throughout the text, beautifully articulated in the poignant quote about love for language: “For, if he doesn’t love our Tongan words, if he doesn’t see their beauty, he’ll learn our language as a slave learns to farm our fields…” This resonates deeply, as I, too, believe in the power of words to shape our identities and cultures.
Johnson’s thoughtful research brings authenticity, yet I sometimes felt it bled into the storytelling. Elements like "A Word About…" sections disrupted the narrative flow, and inconsistent handling of Tongan terms occasionally left me feeling distanced from the cultural richness I had hoped to immerse myself in. It was as if I wasn’t quite experiencing a native story, but rather one dressed up for a Western audience.
After traversing the 736 pages of The Wayfinder, I certainly felt I had embarked on a grand adventure. Yet, the overall reading experience left me wanting a little more depth and engagement with the world. I would recommend this historical epic to readers who enjoy adventurous fantasy with a large ensemble cast. If you appreciate tales where power struggles meet the intricacies of culture, The Wayfinder might just be a rewarding journey.
In conclusion, while Johnson’s novel may not fully transport one into the heart of Polynesian traditions, it does stir the spirit of exploration and resilience—qualities that resonate universally. As I closed the book, I couldn’t help but reflect on how stories, much like the flames Kōrero encounters, have the power to consume and transform us, even when they feel a touch familiar.
Discover more about The Wayfinder on GoodReads >>