Book Review: Mistletoe Season: Three Christmas Stories
As the holiday season approaches, my heart is always on the lookout for stories that encapsulate the warmth, joy, and sometimes chaos of Christmas. Enter Mistletoe Season: Three Christmas Stories, a delightful collection from three talented authors—Kathleen Fuller, Sheila Roberts, and Pepper Basham. The quaint gazebo on the cover beckoned to me, promising an escape into cozy romance, and I couldn’t resist diving into this festive read.
The anthology opens with Kathleen Fuller’s Return to Mistletoe, and let me tell you, it set the tone beautifully. The story oozes nostalgia with its themes of reunions and the sweetness of second chances. We meet Emmy, a mother with a vibrant personality and a charming antiques store. Her dynamics with her daughter were heartwarming, reminding me of the real-life connections that make the holidays special. Kieran, the best friend’s brother, brings an Irish flair that’s so swoon-worthy; it’s impossible not to smile when he utters “lass.” Fuller’s sharp humor and warm prose made the romance feel both genuine and entertaining, especially as friends and family conspire to bring these two together.
Next up is Sheila Roberts’ Say No to Mistletoe, which introduced me to the wonderfully relatable Hailey. A romance author with a knack for attracting chaotic situations—and the occasional high school crush—Hailey’s witty first-person narrative had me chuckling from the get-go. Her aversion to the mistletoe became a clever metaphor for her struggles in finding love, and despite her self-inflicted woes, the chemistry between her and Carwyn was palpable. Roberts balances humor with heart, leaving readers not only rooting for Hailey but also chuckling at her antics.
Finally, Pepper Basham wraps up the collection with The Mistletoe Prince, featuring a delightful mix of romcom chaos and royal charm. I adored the banter between Charlotte, affectionately known as Charlie, and Prince Arran. Their hilarious meet-cute quickly spirals into delightful chaos, showcasing Basham’s gift for crafting characters that leap off the page. I particularly appreciated the genuine camaraderie displayed in their quest for the Mistletoe Wish charity, highlighting themes of community and compassion. Basham’s characters feel real; they’re messy, relatable, and ultimately unforgettable.
Overall, Mistletoe Season is a fun and festive treasure that skillfully captures the essence of holiday romance. Each story feels fresh, distinct, and filled with unique voices—you won’t find any copy/paste here! It’s the ideal collection for readers looking to get into the holiday spirit, showcasing diverse characters and endearing narratives that could easily grace a Hallmark movie screen next Christmas. I now find myself eagerly wanting to explore more works by Sheila Roberts, whose style captivated me with lighthearted charm.
If you’re someone who revels in tales of second chances, witty banter, and the allure of Christmas magic, then Mistletoe Season is undoubtedly a book you should consider adding to your holiday reading list. From its nostalgic themes to heartwarming humor, this collection left me smiling and ready to embrace the joy of the season. Each page turned felt like an invitation into a world where love blossoms amidst the twinkling lights and frosty air, putting a sparkle in my heart that will last long after the decorations are put away.
Discover more about Mistletoe Season: Three Christmas Stories on GoodReads >>






